Skip to main content
NYC Education

TACHS vs SHSAT: What Each Test Decides, and Taking Both

TACHS or SHSAT? How the Catholic high school test and the specialized high school test differ for fall 2027, who decides admission, and the winter between the two results.

G

GeniusPrep Team

·8 min read
Reviewed by the GeniusPrep Tutoring Team — fact-checked against College Board, ACT, ERB and NYC DOE sources. Our editorial standards.
Diagram comparing the TACHS and the SHSAT: registration, where the test is taken, how the score is used, when families hear

Have a question about your child's prep?

5.0 on Google · 14 reviews

No obligation, ask us anything. Diagnostic session is $150 if you decide to book one. Or call (212) 888-3836.

TACHS vs SHSAT: What Each Test Decides, and Taking Both

Many New York 8th graders sit two admissions tests in the same November: the TACHS, for Catholic high schools, and the SHSAT, for the eight specialized public high schools. They are run by different offices, they measure different things, and they feed into two admissions systems that never talk to each other. Your child can take both. The timing to plan for is the winter, when the Catholic schools answer before the SHSAT offer arrives.

Here is how the two compare for September 2027 entry, using the official TACHS calendar and handbook and the NYC Public Schools pages.

Side by side

TACHS SHSAT
For Catholic high schools in the Archdiocese of New York, the Diocese of Brooklyn/Queens and the Diocese of Rockville Centre The eight testing specialized high schools
Who takes it 8th graders, for 9th-grade entry only 8th graders, and 9th graders applying for 10th grade
How often Once: "A student may take the TACHS examination only once" In 8th grade, and again in 9th grade for a 10th-grade seat
Registration Online or by phone with the TACHS office, $78 fee In MySchools, through the NYC Public Schools process
2026 test dates Friday, November 6 (Archdiocese of New York); Saturday, November 7 (Brooklyn/Queens and Rockville Centre) November 14/15 and November 21 (weekends), Wednesday, November 18 (School Day)
Where Online, at home, on a laptop, desktop or Chromebook with webcam (Proctorio) On a DOE computer, at the student's school on School Day or at an assigned weekend site
Format Six timed sub-tests across four areas (Reading, Written Expression, Mathematics, Ability), about 2 hours 10 minutes at standard time 50 ELA and 50 Mathematics questions, 180 minutes, computer-adaptive
New in 2026 A 4-function calculator inside the test, on eligible portions The test became computer-adaptive
What decides admission The score is one part of the file, with grades, conduct, effort and attendance The score alone
When families hear Earliest notices January 13 (Brooklyn/Queens, Rockville Centre) and January 20, 2027 (Archdiocese) March 3, 2027, with the public high school offer

The TACHS dates and rules come from the TACHS Parent/Student Calendar and the 2026 Student Handbook; the SHSAT facts from NYC Public Schools. The TACHS is behind us for this year; the SHSAT is still ahead (November 14/15, 18 and 21), so the questions that matter now are about what happens next.

What each test is actually measuring

The TACHS has four parts. Reading and Written Expression look like a school English test: comprehension, word meaning in context, sentence structure, spotting the line with an error. Mathematics covers number sense, algebraic patterns, data and probability, geometry and measurement. The fourth part, Ability, is the one families do not expect: reasoning with shapes and figures, in question types the handbook calls Figure Matrices, Paper Folding and Figure Classification. There is no penalty for a wrong answer, and once a sub-test is submitted the student cannot go back to it.

The SHSAT has two sections, English Language Arts and Mathematics, with 50 questions each and three hours in total, split however the student chooses. Since fall 2026 it is computer-adaptive: the difficulty adjusts to the student's answers, and outside an open ELA passage set the student cannot return to a question already passed. Our page on how the SHSAT works this year goes through it in detail.

A student strong in school math and reading but uneasy with abstract figure puzzles may find the TACHS Ability section harder than anything on the SHSAT. One who reads fast and accurately but has gaps in pre-algebra may find the SHSAT math harder.

How the result is used

This is where the two systems split completely.

At a Catholic high school, the TACHS score goes to the three high schools your child chose, with an Applicant Record: final grades for 6th and 7th grade, the first quarter or trimester of 8th grade, any standardized test results, and conduct, effort and attendance. Each school decides on its own admissions and its own scholarships and financial aid. Scores go to the schools on or before December 7; for public school students, the Applicant Record is due at each school by December 11, 2026.

At a specialized high school, admission depends on the SHSAT score alone: the city converts the two section scores into a composite "used for rank ordering." Grades, attendance and interviews play no part. (LaGuardia, the ninth specialized school, admits by audition and does not use the SHSAT.)

A weaker test day therefore weighs differently. On the TACHS it is one piece of a file the school reads. On the SHSAT it is the only factor.

The winter between TACHS notices and SHSAT offers

The winter in between

For families who took both, the calendar is the real issue.

  1. By December 7: TACHS scores go to your three Catholic high schools.
  2. January 13 or January 20: the earliest Catholic admission notices go out, depending on the diocese.
  3. January 22, 2027: the TACHS Home Report opens online, with local and national percentile ranks.
  4. March 3, 2027: public high school offers and SHSAT results arrive in MySchools.

A Catholic school may need your answer before you know whether your child has a specialized high school seat. Each Catholic high school sets its own reply date and its own deposit terms; the TACHS office does not. Before January, ask each school on your list two questions: when do you need our decision, and is the registration deposit refundable if our child accepts a public school seat in March? Write the answers down next to each school's name.

Remember too that the public high school application is separate from the SHSAT. It closes on Friday, December 4, 2026, and most families list 12 programs on it, including some screened programs (see our guide to screened high schools for fall 2027). A student who took the SHSAT still needs that application to have a public school offer on March 3 if the SHSAT does not lead to a specialized seat.

If your child is in 7th grade now

Next fall you will face the same choice. A few things to know early:

  • Registration windows differ. For this cycle, TACHS registration ran from August 24 to October 28, 2026; SHSAT registration ran from October 6 to October 30. Extended-time requests for the TACHS closed earlier still, on October 2, and went to each diocese.
  • Accommodations differ. On the TACHS, the only accommodation allowed is extended time (time and a half). On the SHSAT, accommodations listed in an IEP or 504 plan carry over, and English Language Learners get 360 minutes. Our guide to extended time on admissions tests covers both.
  • Preparation overlaps, but not fully. Reading comprehension and core math transfer between the two. The TACHS Ability section and the adaptive format of the SHSAT each need their own practice.

For the TACHS, we have written free TACHS-style practice questions for each part, and our TACHS page keeps the full official calendar. For the SHSAT, see the SHSAT test dates and our 1-on-1 SHSAT prep.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can my child take both the TACHS and the SHSAT? Yes. They are run by different offices, with separate registrations, and neither affects the other.

Which is harder, the TACHS or the SHSAT? They test different things. The SHSAT is longer, adaptive and decides admission on its own. The TACHS adds a figure-reasoning section and, since 2026, a basic calculator inside the test, but is read alongside grades and conduct.

Can you retake the TACHS? No. The handbook states that a student may take the TACHS only once, and that results are final, with no rescoring or retesting.

When do TACHS results come out? Scores are sent to the three chosen high schools on or before December 7, 2026. Families see the Home Report online after 3:00 PM ET on Friday, January 22, 2027. Admission notices start on January 13 or January 20, depending on the diocese.

When do SHSAT results come out? With the high school offers, in MySchools, on Wednesday, March 3, 2027, after 3 PM.

Do Catholic high schools see SHSAT scores? The TACHS sends its own scores to your three chosen Catholic schools. The Applicant Record asks for any standardized test results, so check with each school what it wants included.

Sources


Reviewed by the GeniusPrep Tutoring Team — last updated 2026-11-16. TACHS dates were read on the official TACHS calendar and handbook; SHSAT facts on NYC Public Schools pages. If you see something out of date, contact us.

#TACHS vs SHSAT#TACHS#SHSAT#Catholic high schools NYC#specialized high schools

Share this article

Take the next step

Ready to boost your child’s scores?

Book a 90-minute diagnostic — we evaluate your child’s current level, set a target, and build a written prep plan.

5.0 on Google · 14 reviews

No obligation, ask us anything. Diagnostic session is $150 if you decide to book one. Or call (212) 888-3836 · 928 Broadway, Flatiron · No contracts, pay per session

Continue Reading

All articles →
Call now Book — $150